A Practical Approach to Arbitration
Andrew has served as a neutral arbitrator in a wide range of cases where parties seek a binding resolution outside of litigation. With over 30 years of legal experience and a background in subrogation, insurance disputes, and civil litigation, Andrew brings both legal depth and practical judgment to the arbitration process.
Whether chosen as a sole arbitrator or as part of a three-member panel, Andrew is known for his clear reasoning, efficient case management, and respectful treatment of all parties.
Why Choose Andrew Toubin as Your Arbitrator?
Deep Legal Knowledge
Licensed since 1992, Andrew has litigated and mediated hundreds of cases—particularly in insurance, subrogation, contract, and civil matters.
Balanced & Neutral Judgment
Having represented both plaintiffs and insurance carriers, Andrew offers a well-rounded perspective and a strong commitment to neutrality.
Procedurally Efficient
Andrew’s organized, communicative style ensures the arbitration process moves forward without unnecessary delays.
Clear, Respectful Decision-Making
He is known for issuing thoughtful, well-explained decisions and maintaining a professional, cooperative tone throughout proceedings.
Types of Cases Arbitrated
Andrew accepts appointments as an arbitrator in the following types of civil disputes:
Insurance subrogation matters
Breach of contract and commercial disputes
Construction defect or delay claims
Property damage cases
Title disputes
Personal injury claims (by agreement)
Collections or debt-related disputes
He is available for both solo arbitration and panel arbitration (as one of three neutrals), depending on the parties’ agreement.
Arbitration Process Overview
Step 1) Appointment
Once parties agree to use Andrew as their arbitrator, he will confirm availability and provide fee information and scheduling options after a consultation.
Step 2) Case Materials
Parties may submit pre-hearing materials or summaries depending on case complexity.
Step 3) Hearing
Arbitrations may be held virtually or in-person. Andrew ensures each side has a fair opportunity to present their case.
Step 4) Decision
After reviewing evidence and testimony, Andrew provides a written, binding decision unless otherwise agreed upon.
Customized Arbitrations
Customized Fee Structure – Fees are tailored to the complexity and duration of each arbitration case.
- Andrew provides neutral dispute resolution as an impartial arbitrator, helping both parties reach binding decisions efficiently and privately.
- With flexible scheduling and the option for single arbitrator or panel (typically 3) arbitrations, Andrew offers a confidential and cost-effective alternative to litigation.
- Consultation Required – Contact Andrew to discuss your arbitration needs and receive a detailed fee estimate.
**Please Note: Andrew will only accept arbitrations if both parties agree to use him in either a single or as a panel (typically 3). Contact Andrew directly for more information.
Frequently Asked Questions
Arbitration is a binding dispute resolution process in which a neutral third party (the arbitrator) hears arguments, reviews evidence, and makes a final decision. Unlike mediation—where the mediator facilitates negotiation without imposing an outcome—an arbitrator issues a ruling that typically cannot be appealed.
Yes. Andrew serves as both a sole arbitrator or as part of a three-arbitrator panel, depending on what the parties agree to in advance.
Andrew is available for civil and commercial disputes, including subrogation, breach of contract, construction, property damage, title disputes, and collection matters. He may also arbitrate personal injury claims if both parties agree.
Yes. Andrew offers flexible scheduling and can conduct arbitrations via secure Zoom links or in person, depending on the parties’ preference and case complexity.
Timeframes vary based on case complexity, but Andrew emphasizes efficiency and communication throughout. Once appointed, he works with the parties to schedule hearings promptly and issue decisions in a timely manner.