What is Mediation?
Mediation is an alternative dispute resolution method in which parties work with a neutral third party—the mediator—to reach a mutually acceptable settlement. Unlike a judge or arbitrator, a mediator does not make decisions or determine outcomes. Instead, they facilitate open communication, helping both sides identify solutions and reach common ground.
For many, mediation is a welcome alternative to the uncertainty and expense of litigation. It offers privacy, flexibility, and most importantly—control over the outcome.
Why Choose Mediation with Andrew Toubin?
Decades of Experience
Practicing law since 1992 and mediating since 2004, Andrew brings a deep understanding of both legal strategy and interpersonal dynamics.
Dual-Perspective Insight
With a career rooted in subrogation and experience representing both plaintiffs and insurers, Andrew knows how both sides approach negotiations—helping bridge gaps faster.
Flexible Scheduling
Full-day, half-day, and evening sessions are available. Andrew also offers “stacked mediations” for clients handling multiple small claims.
Creative Problem-Solving
Known for his practical mindset and settlement creativity, Andrew goes beyond number shuttling to find meaningful, lasting agreements.
Types of Disputes Mediated
Andrew offers in-person and virtual mediation services for a wide range of civil disputes, including:
Personal injury & auto accident claims
Insurance subrogation
Contract & construction disputes
Title disputes
Collection matters
Credit card debt settlement
Landlord/tenant conflicts
Workers’ compensation-related mediation
Other civil or commercial disputes by request
Andrew’s Mediation Process
Step 1) Scheduling
Once both parties agree to mediate with Andrew, you can schedule a session using our Calendar online. Andrew will send a confirmation email once everything is set.
Step 2) Preparation
Parties may submit informal mediation memos outlining key issues—though this is optional in most cases.
Step 3) Session Day
Andrew begins with a clear, welcoming opening conference. Sessions may involve joint and private caucuses to foster communication and progress.
Step 4) Extended Support
If the case doesn’t settle, Andrew offers follow-up or reconvening options and remains available to assist with implementation hiccups.
A successful mediation is a process where both sides walk away a little frustrated—but ultimately relieved—because they made the decision to resolve it. I don’t force settlements. I help people make their own.
-Andrew Toubin
Flexible Mediation Options & Fees
Half-Day (4 hours): $495
Full-Day (8 hours): $995
Short 2-Hour Mediation (e.g., credit card disputes): $250 per party
Extended Time: $100/hr per party (only charged if significant overage applies)
Stacked Mediations: Available for clients handling multiple related matters in a single day—efficient and cost-effective
Evening sessions are also available, typically from 6–8pm or longer if needed.
Cancellation Policy: $100/party if canceled within 24 hours. Flexible with rescheduling.
Frequently Asked Questions
If both parties agree to a settlement, it becomes a binding contract. If not, the case can still proceed to trial.
While not required, legal counsel can help you understand your rights and outcomes. Andrew does not provide legal advice in his role as a mediator.
The parties may reconvene at a later date or proceed with litigation. Andrew remains available for follow-up.
Bring any relevant documents, your attorney (if applicable), and an open mind. This is your opportunity to help shape the outcome.
Yes. Andrew regularly mediates via Zoom and provides secure links in advance.